Cinemaroll > Action

Spiderman 3 - Fun but Flawed

I went and saw it yesterday, not exactly brilliant, but well worth seeing.

I'm a comic book geek. There's no other way of looking at it. So of course, Spiderman 3 was a film I was looking forward to. And rightly so, Sam Raimi's done it again. Fusing the ever-present angst of the series with a mad humor reminiscent of his earlier films (Army of Darkness anyone? Bruce Dickinson even has a hilarious cameo as an officious waiter.)

Content-wise, this is a weaker film. The Venom backstory is too much to fit into one film, the black suit really needs a film to itself, but alas, it doesn't, leaving Venom itself to have a pitiful amount of screen time. Granted the symbiote creature is beautifully rendered, but Venom just becomes boring. Sandman was another strange choice for a villain, a weaker character in the comics, but presented here as a nicely rounded figure. And of course, the Osborn family are back once again, raging green psychotic terror (and allowing Willem Dafoe a cameo, hurrah!).

So while James Franco (as Harry Osborn) and the wonderful Tobey Maguire have a lot of fun being angsty, dorky, violent, and occasionally pretty campy, poor Kirstin Dunst has to resign herself to screaming and singing (or miming, and badly dubbed at that) as the unfortunate Mary Jane Watson. Poor MJ, she really isn't lucky in love is she? The supporting cast range from marvelous (Thomas Haden Church's Sandman) to ridiculous (Topher Grace's one-dimensional Eddie Brock). The comic-book name dropping is getting ridiculous too, Gwen Stacy and Dr Connors are thrown into the mix, and don't add much.

Yet all of these flaws are forgivable, thanks to lovely performances from some of the central roles and Raimi's delightful direction. As well as including some genuinely beautiful shots, there's some really hilarious sequences when Peter Parker is experimenting with the powers of the black suit (his hair changes color every time he wears it, too, which is a nice touch). These scenes are so good they could easily be reedited into an arty short piece on drug addiction, but it's a lovely change from the angst and silly pseudo-science of the rest of the film. The climactic battle is a thing of beauty, recalling the brutality of the first film, and, even though some things in it should NEVER happen in the context of Spiderman, it touched a little fan girl nerve.

If you're a fan of superheroes, or just want a fun few hours escapism with good old Hollywood silliness, go see this film. Don't expect the dark delights of the first film, or the unrepentant cool of the second, but go, grab some popcorn and settle in for fun CGI, interesting characters, and a delicious streak of surreal humor.

9
Liked It
I Like It!
Related Articles
A.j.'s Film Fanaticism: Spiderman 3 Review  |  Seven Movies You Should Never Put Yourself Through
More Articles by Emma C. S.
Control: A Film Review  |  Movie Review: Sweeney Todd, the Demon Barber of Fleet Street
Latest Articles in Action
Fight Club Movie Analysis  |  James Bond 007 Quantum of Solace Previewed
Comments (6)
#1 by Lucy Lockett, May 17, 2007
That surprised me, you liking Spiderman and being a comic book fan!You learn new things every day. A good review by the way.
#2 by Gail Nobles, May 25, 2007
I have seen Spiderman 3. It is the comic book that came to life. I enjoyed it. They brought out forgiveness in this movie. A lot of people can't forgive. I think it was a great movie and all the characters were exciting.
#3 by Lucy Lockett, Jun 5, 2007
Just stopping by to see how you are doing.
#4 by Gail Nobles, Dec 23, 2007
Hi, Emma!

There is a rumor that the Lizard-Man is going to be in Spider-Man 4.
#5 by Emma C S, Dec 23, 2007
Hey Gail! Ooooh, I hope Lizard is in Spidey 4, he's one of my favourite villains and Dr Connors has had brief appearances in the earlier films so it would make sense. He was rumoured to be in the third film, but I guess that would have been too much.
#6 by harry l , Sep 3, 2008
hey Emma thtat would of been to much personally in my opinion it was too much anyway, i think its also a bit of a tacky film
Post Your Comment:
Name:  
Copy the code into this box:  
Inside Cinemaroll

Action

 /

Adventure

 /

Animation

 /

Cinemarolling

 /

Comedy

 /

Documentary

 /

Drama

 /

Family

 /

Fantasy

 /

History

 /

Horror

 /

Musical

 /

Mystery

 /

Romance

 /

Science Fiction

 /

Thriller

 /

War


Popular Tags
Popular Writers
Cinemaroll
About Us
Terms of Use
Privacy Policy
Services
Submit an Article
Advertise with Us
Contact

© 2007 Copyright Stanza Ltd. All Rights Reserved.